Mark LoMonaco
PerformerBiographical facts
born: 1971-07-14
- Cagematch: 1971-07-14
- ProFightDB: 1971-07-14
birthplace: Massapequa, New York, USA
- Cagematch: Massapequa, New York, USA
- ProFightDB: Massapequa, New York, United States
Portrayals
Combined record
Rolled up across 5 personas this human portrayed: 2967 matches, 1469 wins (across covered promotions).
- Bully Ray: 1743 matches, 869 wins
- Bubba Ray Dudley: 692 matches, 312 wins
- Buh Buh Ray Dudley: 323 matches, 168 wins
- Brother Ray: 184 matches, 96 wins
- Bubba Ray: 25 matches, 24 wins
Title reigns
Match history
| Event | Appeared as (Persona) | Promotion | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IWA Japan Danger & Please Tour '96 - Tag 5: ECW IWA True FMW Total War | Bully Ray | ECW/IWA Japan, International Wrestling Association Japan | Won |
| IWA Japan Danger & Please Tour '96 - Tag 5: ECW IWA True FMW Total War | Bubba Ray Dudley | ECW/IWA Japan, International Wrestling Association Japan | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| APW/TNA Impacto Total - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Associacao Portuguesa de Wrestling | Won |
| UWF/TNA Winners Circle | Bully Ray | United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| UWF/TNA Campus Invasion Night One | Bully Ray | United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| UWF/TNA Qualified For Action | Bully Ray | United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| UWF/TNA Buckle Up Tour - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Buckle Up Tour - Tag 1 | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Won |
| HOG VI | Bully Ray | House Of Glory | Lost |
| HOG VI | Bubba Ray Dudley | House Of Glory | Lost |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, RevPro, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Won |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, RevPro, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Won |
| UWF/TNA Buckle Up Tour - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| UWF/TNA Buckle Up Tour - Tag 2 | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| UWF/TNA Campus Invasion Night Two | Bully Ray | United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| APW/TNA Impacto Total - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Associacao Portuguesa de Wrestling | Won |
| UWF/TNA Monsters Ball | Bully Ray | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Casket Match | Bully Ray | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Casket Match | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Hardcore War | Bully Ray | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| IWA Japan Danger & Please Tour '96 - Tag 6: ECW IWA True FMW Total War | Bully Ray | International Wrestling Association Japan | Lost |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1182 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW A Matter Of Respect 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #95 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #95 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #420 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Backlash 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Backlash 2003 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Superstars #376 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Superstars #376 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #45 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Unforgiven 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Unforgiven 2002 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1195 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Tribute To The Troops 2015 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Tribute To The Troops 2015 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #540 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #139 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #251 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2010 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #187 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #187 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #535 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 1 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1162 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #360 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #489 - Turning Point 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #373 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #373 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #77 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #41 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #41 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ROH State Of The Art 2019 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF Jakked #8 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW It Ain't Seinfeld | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2005 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2005 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #187 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #411 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2010 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #89 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #89 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Living Dangerously 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Living Dangerously 1999 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #523 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #449 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #61 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #61 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #876 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #842 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #315 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum IMPACT Tour 2013 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #258 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #995 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 3 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #406 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWE RAW #507 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #507 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Armageddon 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Armageddon 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Hardcore Justice 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1193 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #504 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW #442 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #95 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #95 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #469 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #469 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1167 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1167 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Victory Road 2014 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2018 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #849 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #849 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Unforgiven 1999 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Unforgiven 1999 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Survivor Series 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| GCW Fight Club 2024 - Tag 1: The Art Of War Games | Bully Ray | Game Changer Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor 2018 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #109 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #543 - Best Of 2014 Part 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #543 - Best Of 2014 Part 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #2 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #546 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #545 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #837 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #837 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #362 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #362 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Big Ass Extreme Bash - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #526 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heatwave 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Cyberslam 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #35 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #35 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary X | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Survivor Series 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #485 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #335 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary 2007 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 10 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Extreme Beach Party | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Extreme Beach Party | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #401 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #164 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #463 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SummerSlam 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #499 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #499 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1207 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #40 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #359 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #298 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #241 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #241 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SummerSlam 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SummerSlam 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #427 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #509 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #410 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA No Surrender 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tag Team Tournament 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tag Team Tournament 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tag Team Tournament 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #213 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #213 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling #988 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling #996 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #292 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #292 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1178 - The Slammy Awards 2015 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1178 - The Slammy Awards 2015 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #199 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #199 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #363 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Heat Wave 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Heat Wave 1998 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #361 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #261 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #261 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #483 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #104 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #104 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Velocity #99 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Ultimate Jeopardy 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #286 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 7 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 7 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #415 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #415 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Unforgiven 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Unforgiven 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #67 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #46 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #46 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #17 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #17 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW One Night Stand 2005 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW One Night Stand 2005 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #185 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Hell In A Cell 2015 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #268 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #209 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #209 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #246 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #1009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #124 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #124 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #36 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #36 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling #975 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #421 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #421 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #430 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #497 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #132 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #132 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #94 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Hardcore Justice 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #497 - Genesis 2014 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #378 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #83 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #50 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #524 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1168 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #247 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #247 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #845 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #845 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #270 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #441 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #441 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Against All Odds 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #142 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #488 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #256 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF No Mercy 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF No Mercy 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Powerrr #90 - The Champions Series 2022: Part 1 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #298 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #298 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #553 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #437 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #437 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #382 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #294 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #426 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #426 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #545 - Top 20 Countdown Part I | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #275 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #275 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW As Good As It Gets | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #233 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #289 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Barely Legal | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Barely Legal | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #412 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #412 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1185 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Royal Rumble 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Royal Rumble 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 6 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 6 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #133 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hostile City Showdown 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #401 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #114 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #114 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #400 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Night Of Champions 2015 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #331 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #428 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #516 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #355 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF RAW #448 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #448 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #420 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #474 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #440 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #865 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #865 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Hardcore Justice 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #75 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #103 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #1003 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2011 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #318 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #397 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #356 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Vengeance 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Vengeance 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1173 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #184 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Superstars #382 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Superstars #382 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #171 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 2 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #368 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Unlucky Lottery | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Unlucky Lottery | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #151 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #151 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #496 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #496 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XV | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Global Impact 2 | Bully Ray | NJPW, Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Global Impact 2 | Brother Ray | NJPW, Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #403 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #112 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #112 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #999 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #475 - Hardcore Justice 2013 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #266 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #266 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #266 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #65 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XV | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #338 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Heat Wave 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Backlash 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Backlash 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #479 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #479 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #439 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #466 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #466 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #226 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #226 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #489 - RAW Roulette 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #272 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #563 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #563 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #78 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #960 - The Best TNA Matches From The UK | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #295 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #522 - Champions Showcase | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #403 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #253 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #246 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #480 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #480 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #162 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #162 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #113 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #113 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #148 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 4 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #372 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Bound For Glory 2022 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #240 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #240 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2008 (Januar) | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2008 (Januar) | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #461 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #521 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds 2010 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Judgment Day 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #248 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #32 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #32 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #839 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #388 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #304 - Draft 2005 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #204 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW #452 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #414 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #406 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| HOG High Intensity 2025 | Bully Ray | House Of Glory | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #259 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #259 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #366 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #156 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Velocity #124 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1183 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1183 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Jakked #126 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #13 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #13 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #391 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #391 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Main Event #198 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #841 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #841 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #407 - Open Fight Night 2012 #1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2025 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #339 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Crossing The Line 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #836 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #190 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #351 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 7 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Winter Blowout | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Winter Blowout | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #278 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #389 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #426 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Judgment Day 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 11 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #459 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #540 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 2 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #17 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #526 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #479 - No Surrender 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2014 | Bully Ray | TNA/WRESTLE-1, Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Cyberslam 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Cyberslam 1999 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #854 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Hard Justice 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #257 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #471 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #68 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1201 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1201 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event #155 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Powerrr #81 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #377 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #377 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #454 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2006 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #483 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #148 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Holiday Hell 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 1 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #274 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #274 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2012 - Tag 5 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Superstars #374 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Superstars #374 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #419 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #430 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #430 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| AJPW | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1206 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #149 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2013 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #405 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| HOG Extreme Warfare! | Bully Ray | House Of Glory | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #196 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #196 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2012 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1169 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #484 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2013 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #145 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2014 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE SummerSlam 2004 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE SummerSlam 2004 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Wrestlepalooza 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Wrestlepalooza 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #180 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #274 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Slammiversary 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #33 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #33 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Unforgiven 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Superstars #353 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW November To Remember 1995 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #327 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #125 - Prime Time Special | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #125 - Prime Time Special | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #97 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #355 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #352 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #524 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #354 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #148 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #26 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #549 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #549 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AJPW | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 14 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #416 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #191 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hostile City Showdown 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #476 - Hardcore Justice 2013 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #410 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #376 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #383 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #80 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #80 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #94 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X 2006 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #20 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #514 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF No Mercy 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Superstars #344 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Superstars #344 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary VIII | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #478 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 8 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling, DDT | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 8 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling, DDT | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #471 - Destination X 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #446 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW November To Remember 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW November To Remember 1998 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #24 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #24 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #173 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #173 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #51 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #51 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #149 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #529 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #414 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #121 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #216 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Ultra Clash 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Heat Wave 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #424 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #314 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW High Incident | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #192 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #192 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #57 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #260 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW G1 Supercard | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF RAW #436 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #472 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #472 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #241 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #279 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #947 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #272 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #270 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #478 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #544 - Best Of 2014 Part 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #544 - Best Of 2014 Part 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #138 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Insurrextion 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Insurrextion 2003 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF No Way Out 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #329 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #308 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #506 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #506 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #365 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2017 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #418 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SummerSlam 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SummerSlam 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 13 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Just Another Night | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Just Another Night | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Backlash 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #336 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #336 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1999 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1999 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #114 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2014 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #874 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2014 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #371 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #371 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH Honor For All 2018 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2011 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #70 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #70 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #304 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE RAW #515 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #498 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #498 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #243 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH State Of The Art 2019 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #467 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #467 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #376 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 5 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2018 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #106 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Velocity #126 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Velocity #126 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW When Worlds Collide 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #447 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #120 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #120 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #121 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #271 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #105 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #335 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2016 Kickoff | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #76 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #76 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Velocity #125 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #445 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #29 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #29 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #450 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #465 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #465 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #532 - No Surrender 2014 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #304 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #304 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #494 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #494 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tournament Of Champions 2013 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Royal Rumble 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #364 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #550 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #290 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #249 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #249 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #504 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| NWA USA #34 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #201 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #150 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #265 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #295 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling, FMW/ECW | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #295 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling, FMW/ECW | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #413 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Hardcore Justice 2010 - The Last Stand | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Hardcore Justice 2010 - The Last Stand | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #521 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #495 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #495 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #91 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #396 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 8 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #66 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #66 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Bound For Glory 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #385 - Thanksgiving Special 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #420 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #176 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #176 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #475 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #475 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary XII | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #316 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #856 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Jakked #106 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #44 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Genesis 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #355 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #16 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #107 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #289 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Unauthorized | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #485 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #381 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #383 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Over Drive 2022 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Holiday Hell 1995 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #930 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #330 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #74 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #357 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #419 - Open Fight Night 2012 #4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #477 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #451 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #265 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Insurrextion 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Insurrextion 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 5 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #257 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #257 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WrestleMania XX - "Where it all Begins... Again" | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #375 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #343 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW House Party 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor XI | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #19 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #19 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #87 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Superstars #368 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #190 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #190 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Bad Blood 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #431 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #443 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #84 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #206 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2008 (Dezember) | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #843 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #843 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1188 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #417 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #417 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #302 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #302 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #1000 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #262 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #262 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #53 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #429 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #280 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Genesis 2005 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Genesis 2005 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW #435 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW A Matter Of Respect 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2015 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2015 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1165 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1165 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #959 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2007 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #23 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice 2010 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #255 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #306 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #266 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #218 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #218 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #458 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Cyberslam 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #564 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Royal Rumble 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Royal Rumble 2002 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2015 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Destination X 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 6 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #334 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #334 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #434 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #434 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #179 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AJPW The Unchained World | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #249 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #115 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #115 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #115 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #115 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #259 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #215 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #330 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JCP Ric Flair's Last Match | Bully Ray | Jim Crockett Promotions | Lost |
| WWF RAW #438 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #438 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #493 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #428 - Open Fight Night 2012 #6 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #311 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #402 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1177 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1177 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #482 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #482 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1180 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1180 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #374 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #533 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #533 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #470 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #470 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW House Party 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #99 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1163 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1163 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1212 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW #460 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW #460 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2009 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #415 - Open Fight Night 2012 #3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #135 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #240 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WrestleMania 32 Kickoff | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #177 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #381 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #370 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Armageddon 1999 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Armageddon 1999 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #128 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #345 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #345 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Sacrifice 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - #OldSchool | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #242 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling #978 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Rebellion 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Rebellion 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #88 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #88 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #285 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event #168 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #421 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #547 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Main Event #174 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #283 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Powerrr #92 - The Champions Series 2022: Part 5 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #484 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #613 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2019 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #271 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #271 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Hard Justice 2009 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #215 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #215 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #137 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #137 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #433 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #73 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #73 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #1006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #155 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #155 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #370 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #370 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #105 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE No Mercy 2004 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE No Mercy 2004 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #391 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1199 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #223 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #223 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2013 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #107 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #107 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #853 - Super SmackDown | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #396 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #295 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling, FMW/ECW | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #414 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #131 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #353 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Stardom American Dream 2024 In The Keystone State | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling, World Wonder Ring Stardom, WrestleCon | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1198 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1198 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #367 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #367 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #379 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #956 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Better Than Ever | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #250 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #543 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #543 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 9 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #308 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds 2006 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #122 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #122 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #204 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #532 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #243 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Jakked #62 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Jakked #62 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF/WCW/ECW Invasion | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #282 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #557 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #531 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #406 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event #175 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor XII | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ECW Cyberslam 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Fright Fight | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Fright Fight | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #159 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #159 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Natural Born Killaz | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2017 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #91 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #91 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE The Great American Bash 2004 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE The Great American Bash 2004 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #60 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW #440 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| NWA 312 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| NWA 74 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #267 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Gateway To Honor 2020 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 6 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #180 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Masters Of The Craft 2017 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #268 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #405 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #47 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #47 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #346 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #346 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #55 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #55 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 8 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 8 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #269 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #295 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW December To Dismember 1995 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1194 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1194 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #288 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event #199 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WrestleMania 2000 - "A McMahon In Every Corner" | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #39 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #39 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #292 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2020 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #384 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #384 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #69 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #130 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #422 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #63 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #63 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Memorial Mayhem | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #323 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #423 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #374 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #973 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #487 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #219 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #293 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #214 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary XI | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1211 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #866 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #866 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #517 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #517 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #482 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #93 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Maximum IMPACT Tour 2012 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum IMPACT Tour 2012 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Big Ass Extreme Bash - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #501 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Heat Wave 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Heat Wave 1999 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #134 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #474 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Super Tuesday | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Emergence 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #228 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #464 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #129 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #129 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #368 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #368 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 10 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 10 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #225 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Survivor Series 2015 Kickoff | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Main Event #188 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #188 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event #154 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Main Event #154 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| NWA Powerrr #108 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1166 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1166 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #268 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #305 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Velocity #118 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Velocity #118 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #34 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #34 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #63 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #63 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 7 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #451 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #448 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #287 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event #194 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #245 | Bubba Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling, FMW, NJPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #279 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #279 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #555 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2017 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ECW November To Remember 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW November To Remember 1997 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #945 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Powerrr #94 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #4 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #538 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory IV | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory IV | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #501 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #861 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #861 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Memorial Mayhem | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum IMPACT Tour 2012 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #30 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #43 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #43 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #85 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #85 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Armageddon 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Armageddon 2003 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF No Way Out 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA One Night Only - World Cup 2014 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - World Cup 2014 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Superstars #381 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Superstars #381 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WrestleMania X-Seven - "Houston... We Have A Problem" | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WrestleMania X-Seven - "Houston... We Have A Problem" | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #380 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Genesis 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Genesis 2007 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Judgment Day 2004 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Judgment Day 2004 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #177 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #177 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #372 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2008 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2008 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #70 - 2 Hour Prime Time Special | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #508 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #850 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #31 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #31 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #548 - RAW Roulette 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #365 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Best In The World 2018 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #525 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum IMPACT Tour 2012 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #535 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #332 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #363 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #103 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #103 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #486 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #486 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1175 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1175 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1175 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1175 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #336 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #336 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2018 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE SummerSlam 2016 Kickoff | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH 15th Anniversary Show | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 4 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #267 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #288 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Big Apple Blizzard Blast | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #394 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #468 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #468 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 8 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Destination X 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 9 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 9 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #422 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #344 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #344 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2018 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE RAW #529 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #529 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Wrestlepalooza 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #110 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #110 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2017 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #86 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #86 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #147 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #147 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #478 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Global Impact | Brother Ray | NJPW, Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #117 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #867 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2007 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1170 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #363 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1191 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1191 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Guilty As Charged 1999 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Guilty As Charged 1999 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #158 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1200 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1200 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #301 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #301 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #47 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #77 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #98 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Survivor Series 1999 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #60 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #60 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #260 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #260 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #73 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 6 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 6 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #390 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| CWA | Bubba Ray | Continental Wrestling Association | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #242 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #457 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW #449 - Year In Review Special | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #262 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #432 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #245 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #425 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #125 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1170 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #162 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #399 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Unforgiven 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #350 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #959 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Orgy Of Violence | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #123 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF No Way Out 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF No Way Out 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #476 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #476 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #476 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #476 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #198 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hardcore TV #313 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road To G1 Supercard - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #70 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2010 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #528 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #528 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #52 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #158 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Superstars #380 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #119 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #119 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #349 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #349 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #349 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #98 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #71 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #513 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #513 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #62 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #58 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #58 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #189 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| HOG Philadelphia | Bully Ray | House Of Glory | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling #966 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum IMPACT Tour 2013 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #349 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #111 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #111 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2011 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Insurrextion 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Insurrextion 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #93 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #462 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 4 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ECW on TNN #2 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW November To Remember 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #82 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #170 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA BaseBrawl 2014 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Massacre On Queens Boulevard | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #97 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #97 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #104 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #104 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #108 - Tuesday SmackDown | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #486 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #382 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #357 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #386 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #28 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #28 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #408 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #273 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #182 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #502 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #495 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #131 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #131 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #423 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hostile City Showdown 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #16 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #7 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #542 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 9 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #398 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Armageddon 2003 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Armageddon 2003 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #422 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #264 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #264 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #353 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #363 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #953 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Rebellion 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Rebellion 2001 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #492 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Velocity #110 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Velocity #110 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2017 - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #365 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #365 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling #977 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #397 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #203 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #389 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #862 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary IX | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #118 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Slammiversary Tour - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #285 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #41 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Jakked #41 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #424 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #424 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #424 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #424 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road 2010 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #208 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #208 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #125 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 6 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #517 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #67 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #67 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #505 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1131 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #196 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #258 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SmackDown #258 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE SmackDown #258 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #118 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1176 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1176 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Armageddon 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Armageddon 2002 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #465 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #395 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 3 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #481 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #343 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #66 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #66 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds 2011 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #467 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2017 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #427 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #427 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH State Of The Art 2018 - Tag 1 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #82 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1174 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #143 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #83 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #83 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat (International Version) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #236 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #424 - Open Fight Night 2012 #5 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #424 - Open Fight Night 2012 #5 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 5 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 5 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night RAW #1197 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #491 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE RAW #491 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #132 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary 2009 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary 2009 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #418 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #196 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #196 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Survivor Series 2003 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW #464 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #311 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #217 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #246 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #246 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #352 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #13 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #13 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #546 - Top 20 Countdown Part II | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE NXT #758 - NXT 2300 | Bully Ray | NXT, World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE NXT #758 - NXT 2300 | Bubba Ray Dudley | NXT, World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #367 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #971 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Honor United - Tag 2 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ECW Born To Be Wired | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #351 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Vengeance 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #342 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #342 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #130 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #130 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Money In The Bank 2016 Kickoff | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #242 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #848 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Thursday Night SmackDown #848 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #11 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #154 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #290 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #344 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #92 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #360 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #554 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #554 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #23 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Jakked #23 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Survivor Series 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #290 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #290 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Genesis 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #166 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #269 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor United - Tag 3 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Ten Reunion | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Hardcore Justice 3 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #119 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Gateway To Gold | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| IMPACT Wrestling #527 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW on TNN #2 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE RAW #537 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #537 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Velocity #116 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 5 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Shining Series 2005 - Tag 5 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Live From MSG: Lesnar Vs. Big Show | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Live From MSG: Lesnar Vs. Big Show | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #494 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #98 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore TV #231 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 7 | Bully Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| AJPW Real World Tag League 2005 - Tag 7 | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE RAW #522 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE RAW #522 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice 2012 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #961 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #102 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1997 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1997 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven 1997 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #369 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #369 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #394 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #394 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #21 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #21 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Hard To Kill 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #946 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #530 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Judgment Day 2002 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2004 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2004 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #511 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #116 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #195 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #172 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WrestleMania X8 - "The One And Only" | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WrestleMania X8 - "The One And Only" | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #347 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #200 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #90 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #400 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF King Of The Ring 2001 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF RAW is WAR #432 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Ultimate Jeopardy '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #25 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Lost |
| ECW Buffalo Show (Apr '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Night of Champions '15 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Wrestlemania Revenge Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Survivor Series '01 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| NEW Holiday Havoc 2006 | Brother Ray | NEW | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hostile City Showdown '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Big Ass Extreme Bash - Night 2 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| PWS Spring Breakdown 2015 | Bully Ray | PWS | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Oct '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE SummerSlam '03 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #956 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2020 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF InVasion | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Warrior Wrestling #8 | Bully Ray | Warrior Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor XVI - Night 2 TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat (International) Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Bound for Glory '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Saturday Night at Center Stage | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF King of the Ring '01 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW CyberSlam '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE MSG Show (Feb '03) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| MLP Forged In Excellence - Day 1 | Bully Ray | MLP | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #951 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #962 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #954 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| PWS Super Card 2015 | Bully Ray | PWS | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #501 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW House Party '97 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Victory Road 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #361 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF RAW is WAR #361 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Judgment Day 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Judgment Day 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling #1014 - Best Of 2023 Part 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #72 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF SmackDown #72 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA One Night Only - Joker's Wild 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Joker's Wild 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF King Of The Ring 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW House Party 1996 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Living Dangerously 1998 | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Living Dangerously 1998 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #395 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| IMPACT Wrestling #450 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Monaca Show (Aug '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown '10 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #482 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Fort Lauderdale Show (Feb '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Scranton Show (Jan '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #8 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| NJPW Dominion 6.20 | Brother Ray | NJPW | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| HUSTLE PPV 20 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tag Team Tournament Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tag Team Tournament Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Tag Team Tournament Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Queens Show (Dec '00) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| UWF (Carolina)/MCW Fort Meade Show (Jun '07) | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina)/MCW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WSW International Assault Tour 2005 - Day 3 | Brother Ray | WSW | Won |
| GCW Fight Club 2024 - Day 1: The Art Of War Games | Bully Ray | Game Changer Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #995 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 2 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| House of Hardcore #24 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| ROH Best in the World '17 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| 2CW Super Kicks In The Southern Tier | Bubba Ray Dudley | 2CW | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road '06 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF MSG Show (Jun '00) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Queens Show (Aug '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Queens Show (Aug '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary VIII | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW November To Remember '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Dover Show (Mar '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Bad Blood '03 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE MSG Show (Mar. '16) - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH Charm City Excellence - TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH State of the Art 2019 - Day 1 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat (International) Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Scranton Show (Mar '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Apr '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling Debut Show | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Mar '99 #2) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2018 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| OVW TV Taping (March '05 #4) | Bubba Ray Dudley | OVW | Won |
| HUSTLE House Vol. 16 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| NEW Wrestlefest XXIII | Bully Ray | NEW | Won |
| TNA Victory Road '11 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW New Orleans Show | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Hostile City Showdown '98 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| House of Hardcore VIII | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Survivor Series '15 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Mt. Lebanon Show (Nov '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Mt. Lebanon Show (Jan '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW New York City Show (Dec '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| HUSTLE HustleAid '06 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WrestleReunion #3: When Legends Collide | Brother Ray | WrestleReunion | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Against All Odds 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Against All Odds 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF King Of The Ring 2000 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #64 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #64 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2006 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2006 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Road To Lockdown Tour - Tag 7 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF SmackDown #101 | Bully Ray | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW | Bully Ray | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Genesis '11 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Buffalo Show (Dec '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Survivor Series '02 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| NWA Powerrr S12E3 Taping | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Lost |
| TNA One Night Only: Victory Road '14 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Jun '98 #1) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Nov '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Hell In A Cell 2015 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Extreme Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| MLP Forged In Excellence - Day 2 | Bully Ray | MLP | Lost |
| ECW Queens Show (Nov '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Toledo Show (Aug '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Binghamton Show (Mar '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW/IWA Japan Tokyo Show (Aug '96) | Bubba Ray Dudley | ECW/IWA Japan | Lost |
| ECW Holiday Hell '95 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Super Smackdown! Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #33 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WCPW Loaded #20 | Bully Ray | WCPW | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Monaca Show (Mar '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #67 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Holiday Hell '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Powerrr S11E9 - Powerrr LIVE! | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Bound for Glory '13 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Backlash '01 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| NWA Powerrr S11E6 - The Champions Series Part 3 (airdate) | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Jul '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping: Hardcore Justice '13 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping #522 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW High Incident | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Hardcore Homecoming Extreme Reunion Tour - Night 1 | Brother Ray | Hardcore Homecoming | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling The Witching Hour | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Won |
| HUSTLE PPV 14 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF/IWA Puerto Rico Ponce Show (Apr '00) | Bubba Ray Dudley | WWF/IWA Puerto Rico | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Orgy Of Violence | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #991 Taping - Part 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Smackdown Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Velocity Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| NEW Wrestlefest XXVI | Bully Ray | NEW | Lost |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping - Destination X '13 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '10 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road to WrestleMania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2025 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Staten Island Show (Nov '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! #509 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF No Mercy '00 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF No Mercy '00 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #517 pt. 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 1 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Detroit Show (May '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Jakked #47 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2017 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 4 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Heat Wave '97 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| House of Hardcore #32 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| ECW Waltham Show (Mar '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| House of Hardcore #56 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #56 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Dalton Show (Oct '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW G1 SuperCard | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #49 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary '06 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW New York City Show (Nov '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Hardcore Heaven '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE No Mercy '04 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WrestleMania 2000 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling Turn Up The Heat | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Money In The Bank '16 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Slammiversary 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #181 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Jun '98 #3) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF MSG Show (Oct '01) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution (Dec '08) | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2019 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW It Ain't Seinfeld | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping #521 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Better Than Ever | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Jan '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF No Way Out '02 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| 2CW Nightmare Before Christmas 2014 | Bubba Ray Dudley | 2CW | Won |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling Tribute To The Extreme | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #485 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW As Good As It Gets | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ALL IN | Bully Ray | N/A | Lost |
| WWE Velocity Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Staten Island Show (Dec '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Super Tuesday Taping Part 1 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #478 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Wrestlemania Revenge Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Lockdown '06 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #984 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| HUSTLE HustleMania '06 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| ECW House Party '98 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Villa Park Show (Jun '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WSW International Assault Tour 2005 - Day 1 | Brother Ray | WSW | Won |
| NJPW Destruction '09 | Brother Ray | NJPW | Lost |
| WWF MSG Show (Oct '99) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE MSG Show (Jun '02) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Queens Show (Mar '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #82 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #1003 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Velocity Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #60 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| NWA Powerrr S11E4 - The Champions Series Part 1 (airdate) | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| FMW Super Extreme Wrestling War '97 - Day 2 | Bubba Ray Dudley | FMW | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE SummerSlam '16 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Victory Road '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Webster Show (Nov '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| NJPW Wrestle Kingdom IV in Tokyo Dome | Brother Ray | NJPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| OVW TV Taping (February '05 #2) | Bubba Ray Dudley | OVW | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW November To Remember '95 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| House of Hardcore #26 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2017 | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WCPW Delete WCPW | Bully Ray | WCPW | Won |
| WWE Survivor Series '03 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #77 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Turning Point '10 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Queens Show (Oct '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #992 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Superstars Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE MSG Show (Dec '03) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| UWF (Carolina) Colonial Heights Show (Apr '07) | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina) | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Turning Point '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Sunday Night Heat #288 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Orlando Show (Jul '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| House of Hardcore #48 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| HUSTLE House Vol. 12 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| WRESTLE-1 Grand Prix '05 - Second Round | Bubba Ray | WRESTLE-1 | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #46 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #516 pt. 2 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Over Drive 2022 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #2 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (May '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Wrestlemania Revenge Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH Fairfax Excellence | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ECW Wrestlepalooza '98 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Vengeance '02 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling When Worlds Collide | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF MSG Show (Mar '01) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Unforgiven '01 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ROH Gateway to Gold | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Hardcore Justice '11 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Wrestlemania Revenge Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Webster Show (Jan '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Royal Rumble '03 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| 2CW In 3D! | Bubba Ray Dudley | 2CW | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Born To Be Wired | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| HUSTLE PPV 19 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| ECW Staten Island Show | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Windy City Excellence - TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #484 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice '08 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice '08 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Fort Lauderdale Show (Nov '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Destination X '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Oct '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #9 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds '12 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW 1st Anniversary Show: Night of the Barbwire #2 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | JAPW | Lost |
| ECW Cleveland Show (Oct '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling Legends Never Die | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| NWA Powerrr S13E5 Taping | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Buffalo Show (May '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Mar '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '12 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #131 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WCPW KirbyMania | Bully Ray | WCPW | Won |
| ECW Staten Island Show (Aug '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| FMW Super Extreme Wrestling War '97 - Day 3 | Bubba Ray Dudley | FMW | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WrestleReunion #2 | Bubba Ray Dudley | WrestleReunion | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Fight The Power | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| House of Hardcore VII | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Queens Show (Apr '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF MSG Show (Dec '99) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Revere Show (Feb '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Wrestlefanfest Malice in the Palace | Brother Ray | Wrestlefanfest | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling Show #2 | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Won |
| UWF (Carolina) Hardcore War II | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina) | Won |
| WWF Royal Rumble '00 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #106 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Survivor Series '00 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #973 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #971 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds '10 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WrestleMania 32 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Summerslam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Summerslam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WWF WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #969 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| OVW Summer Sizzler Series '05 (#3) | Bubba Ray Dudley | OVW | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Natural Born Killaz | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Royal Rumble '15 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Royal Rumble '16 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF No Way Out '01 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Main Event Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Staten Island Show (Jul '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Staten Island Show (Apr '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW WrestleFest: 50 Years of Funk | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA TNA Live | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| UWF (Carolina) Wilson Show (Feb 07) | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina) | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Jim Thorpe Show (Dec '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WCPW Lights Out | Bully Ray | WCPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #123 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Revere Show (Oct '96) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Queens Show (Feb '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Little Rock Show (Feb '00) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Hostile City Showdown '97 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X '09 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Supercard of Honor XII | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WCPW Loaded #18 | Bully Ray | WCPW | Lost |
| TNA IMPACT Taping #526 Part 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| NWA 312 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW A Matter Of Respect '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| NWA USA S4E5 Taping | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| TNA Bound for Glory '11 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Big Apple Blizzard Blast | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF MSG Show (Sep '00) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Queens Show (Dec '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Queens Show (Dec '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| NWA 74th Anniversary Show - Night 1 | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Superstars Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Thibodeaux Show (Sep '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE MSG Show (Dec. '15) - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat (International) Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #511 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW CyberSlam '97 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #93 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WSW International Assault Tour 2005 - Day 2 | Brother Ray | WSW | Won |
| TNA Impact Taping #529 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping #527 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Survivor Series '99 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Buffalo Show (Dec '97) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| HUSTLE House Vol. 21 | Bubba Ray | HUSTLE | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| AJPW The Unchained World | Bubba Ray | All Japan Pro Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road '10 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Jun '98 #2) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Jun '98 #2) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Chalmette Show (Sep '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '07 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF MSG Show (Jan '01) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #479 - No Surrender '13 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Powerrr S10E4 Taping | Bully Ray | National Wrestling Alliance | Won |
| ECW Queens Show (Nov '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #103 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Massacre On Queen's Boulevard | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| FMW Super Extreme Wrestling War '97 - Day 1 | Bubba Ray Dudley | FMW | Lost |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping #524 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWC Lockout 2008: Abdullah the Butcher Retirement Show | Brother Ray | WWC | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road to WrestleMania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #1008 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '06 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping #508 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW A Matter Of Respect '98 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH NYC Excellence | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - World Cup '14 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - World Cup '14 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Concord Township Show (Feb '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Wrestlemania Revenge Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| NJPW Circuit '09 New Japan ISM - Day 9 | Brother Ray | NJPW | Won |
| WWE WWE Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - SummerSlam Heatwave Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Hard To Kill 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Big Ass Extreme Bash - Night 1 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Bound For Glory 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Impact Taping #532 - No Surrender 2014 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Velocity Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Jakked #130 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Mar '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Battleground Championship Wrestling A Champion Shall Rise | Bully Ray | Battleground Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '14 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA Genesis '12 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA One Night Only - Joker's Wild 2014 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - Joker's Wild 2014 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Emergence 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WrestleCon Supershow 2015 | Bully Ray | WrestleCon | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2019 - Day 4 | Bully Ray | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice '08 | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WrestleMania XX | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| House of Hardcore #47 | Bully Ray | House of Hardcore | Won |
| TNA One Night Only - 10 Reunion Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution '12 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping #523 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE Unforgiven '03 | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA Impact Taping #531 Part 1 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| Hardcore Homecoming November Reign | Brother Ray | Hardcore Homecoming | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live - Road To Wrestlemania | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA IMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Queen City Excellence 2017 - TV Tapings | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Winner Takes All - 15th Anniversary | Bully Ray | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WWE Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| UWF (Carolina) Wilmington Show (Feb '07) | Brother Ray | UWF (Carolina) | Lost |
| Impact Wrestling Bound For Glory 2022 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Wilkes-Barre Show (Jul '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Lost |
| ECW Wrestlepalooza '97 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| ECW Wrestlepalooza '97 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Impact #958 Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW House Party '96 | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Smackdown! Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Dalton Show (Jun '99) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Sacrifice 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| WWE WWE Live - Holiday Tour | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Brother Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| Impact Wrestling Victory Road 2023 | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Sunday Night Heat #97 Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWF WWF Live | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| ECW Philadelphia Show (Dec '98) | Buh Buh Ray Dudley | Extreme Championship Wrestling | Won |
| WWF Monday Night Raw | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| WWE WWE Live (Smackdown) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWF Monday Night Raw Taping | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Lost |
| WWE WWE Live (Raw) | Bubba Ray Dudley | World Wrestling Entertainment | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Bully Ray | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |