Jamar Shipman
PerformerBiographical facts
born: 1985-04
- Cagematch: 1985-04-29
- ProFightDB: 1985-04-20
birthplace: Elizabeth, New Jersey, USA
- Cagematch: Elizabeth, New Jersey, USA
- ProFightDB: Elizabeth, New Jersey, United States
Portrayals
Combined record
Rolled up across 3 personas this human portrayed: 1654 matches, 897 wins (across covered promotions).
- Jay Lethal: 1626 matches, 883 wins
- Hydro: 26 matches, 13 wins
- RPM: 2 matches, 1 win
Title reigns
Match history
| Event | Appeared as (Persona) | Promotion | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| NWA FUW Throwdown 6 | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Florida Underground Wrestling | Won |
| IZW | Jay Lethal | Impact Zone Wrestling | Won |
| PCW/ROH SuperShow Of Honor #2 - Show 2 | Jay Lethal | Preston City Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Upstate 8 Tag Team Tournament 2004 | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Upstate | Won |
| NWA Upstate 8 Tag Team Tournament 2004 | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Upstate | Won |
| NWA Upstate 8 Tag Team Tournament 2004 | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Upstate | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #552 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| NWA Wildside TV | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Wildside | Lost |
| PCW/ROH SuperShow Of Honor #2 - Show 1 | Jay Lethal | Preston City Wrestling | Won |
| UWF/TNA Season Finale | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| UWF/TNA War In Williamston | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| NWA Cyberspace SuperBrawl Saturday IV | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Shockwave | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Won |
| IHPW/JCW | Jay Lethal | International High Powered Wrestling | Won |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Lost |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, RevPro, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Lost |
| UWF/TNA South Carolina Invasion - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| Jericho Cruise 2025: Six On The Beach - Tag 4 (Show 1) | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Won |
| AAW Anniversary XI | Jay Lethal | All Action Wrestling | Lost |
| NWA Cyberspace Cybercade 2 | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Cyberspace | Won |
| Jericho Cruise 2025: Six On The Beach - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Lost |
| NWA Upstate A Final Farewell | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Upstate | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise 2023 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Won |
| UWF/TNA The Return To Philadelphia | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| PCW/ROH SuperShow Of Honor #2 - Show 3 | Jay Lethal | Preston City Wrestling | Won |
| PCW/ROH SuperShow Of Honor #2 - Show 4 | Jay Lethal | Preston City Wrestling | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Monsters Ball | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise 2025: Six On The Beach - Tag 2 (Show 1) | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Lost |
| NWA Midwest | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Midwest | Lost |
| JAPW/ROH Collision Course | Jay Lethal | JAPW/ROH, Jersey All Pro Wrestling | Won |
| NWA Midwest No Gimmicks Needed | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Midwest | Lost |
| CMLL Super Viernes - Gran Prix: CMLL Vs. TNA & Leyenda De Plata 2008 | Jay Lethal | CMLL, Consejo Mundial De Lucha Libre | Won |
| UWF/TNA War In Jacksonville | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Monster In Knightdale | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| NWA Upstate Anniversary Anarchy | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Upstate | Won |
| UWF/TNA South Carolina Invasion - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| UWF/TNA Hardcore War | Jay Lethal | United Wrestling Federation | Won |
| Jericho Cruise 2025: Six On The Beach - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Won |
| NWA Midwest | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Midwest | Lost |
| NWA Cyberspace Shockwave TV Taping | Jay Lethal | National Wrestling Alliance Cyberspace | Won |
| Jericho Cruise 2023 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Won |
| RevPro/NJPW/ROH/CMLL War Of The Worlds UK - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Revolution Pro Wrestling | Won |
| Jericho Cruise - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Won |
| UWF/TNA South Carolina Invasion - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina)/TNA, United Wrestling Federation | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #446 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2004 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH YouTube Special Episode #7 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2017: Columbus | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #95 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #378 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #378 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #101 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| CZW F1-Possession: Sentencing Deferred! | Jay Lethal | Combat Zone Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #217 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #496 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #139 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #192 - Road Rage Edition: Conquest Tour | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA No Surrender 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #176 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Michael Bennett's Bachelor Party Hosted By Adam Cole | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #187 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Future Of Honor #1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Revolution 2024 - Zero Hour | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #529 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #348 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #40 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH State Of The Art 2019 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #230 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #205 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH It All Begins | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #50 - Fyter Fest 2022 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #319 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #44 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2010 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2011 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| IWA Mid-South Point Proven | Jay Lethal | IWA Mid-South | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #106 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2014 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2014 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #293 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Fight Of The Century | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #200 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #330 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #111 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH 13th Anniversary: Winner Takes All | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2015 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Charm City Challenge | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Punk: The Final Chapter | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #101 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Weekend Of Thunder - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Road To G1 Supercard - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JCW For Family And Friends | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #325 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #236 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #192 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #242 - Global Wars Preview | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor XV - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #208 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #109 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| JCW It All Ends Here | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #300 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #208 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #178 - Thanksgiving Special 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #415 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH 17th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Tag Wars 2006 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #373 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor Re-United - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor 2022 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #254 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor X - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor X - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #136 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Bitter Friends, Stiffer Enemies | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Bitter Friends, Stiffer Enemies | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2016 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Joe Vs. Punk II | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #241 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Underground | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #187 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #122 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #156 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #218 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #78 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Caged Hostility | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #281 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2005 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2005 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #127 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Epic Encounter | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Epic Encounter | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2006 Pre-Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #371 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #121 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Pursuit - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #25 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2018 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | DDT, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Relentless | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #199 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #199 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Rising Above 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor IX | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #88 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #219 - Winter Is Coming 2023 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| JCW Chaos With The Cops 2 | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2025 - Zero Hour | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #311 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #272 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #282 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #286 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #93 - Road Rage Edition: Best In The World 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrath Of The Racket | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrath Of The Racket | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #125 - Road Rage Edition: Wrestling's Finest | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #100 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Showdown In The Sun - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #14 - Best Of 2011 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor X | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #26 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2017: Chicago | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #154 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #44 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| JCW Demand Respect | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #142 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #85 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Reach For The Sky - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #10 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #541 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Road To G1 Supercard - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Collision #108 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #253 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2016 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH State Of The Art 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #298 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #149 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #550 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #176 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #193 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #281 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #275 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Mass Hysteria | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #309 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Honor United - Newport | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Raising The Bar - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Free Enterprise | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Second Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #170 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #388 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #54 - Road Rage Edition: Death Before Dishonor X | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #97 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #212 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor United - Bolton | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #404 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AAA TripleMania Regia 2021 | Jay Lethal | Lucha Libre AAA World Wide | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH World Title Classic | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH World Title Classic | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #20 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #233 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #37 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #77 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #121 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| HOG High Intensity | Jay Lethal | House Of Glory | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #289 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #179 - Road Rage Edition: Winter Warriors Tour 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor United - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor XIII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2015 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #118 - Adam Cole Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #258 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #512 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #148 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #181 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Generation Next | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Generation Next | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JCW Spring Fever | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Lost |
| CHIKARA Young Lions Cup II - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | CHIKARA | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #208 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #280 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #549 - Jonathan Gresham - A Champion's Journey Part 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #523 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #155 - Royal Rampage 2024 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #186 - Road Rage Edition: Supercard Of Honor IX | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #260 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #135 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #226 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #342 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #116 - Road Rage Edition: Pursuit - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Southern Defiance | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Southern Defiance | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2009 Pre-Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #220 - Holiday Bash 2023 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor Reigns Supreme 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #199 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #133 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #179 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH The Hunt For Gold | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #310 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Defy Or Deny 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle Convention | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle Convention | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Pro Wrestling Guerrilla | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #288 - Monday Night iMPACT | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #549 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #164 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #255 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #317 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #162 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #162 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW House Rules Tour - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #217 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #47 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Boiling Point 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #246 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dark #173 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #266 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #254 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Road To Greatness - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #46 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2008 (Januar) | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #146 - Road Rage Edition: War Of The Worlds | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #69 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2014 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark #149 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Unforgettable | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2015 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2015 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XII - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2017: Buffalo | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Beating The Odds | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Beating The Odds | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Battle Of The Belts III | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #5 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2014 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Aftershock 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #138 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #86 - Road Rage Edition: Border Wars 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Dissension | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Pro Wrestling Guerrilla | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #325 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #366 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #103 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #129 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Turning Point 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #276 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #89 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #89 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #310 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #125 - Prime Time Special | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH 10th Anniversary Show - Young Wolves Rising | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #288 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Collision #19 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #243 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #257 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Revolution 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #323 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Collision #37 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #300 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling's Finest | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #443 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Gateway To Honor 2011 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor 2021 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #59 - Road Rage Edition: Glory By Honor XI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor XII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #444 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2015 - Tag 5 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #54 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #148 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #265 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Elite | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Showdown In The Sun - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor Reigns Supreme 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #172 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #265 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #246 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2016 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #143 - Black Friday | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #100 - Best Of 100 Episodes | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #100 - Best Of 100 Episodes | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #330 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor Reigns Supreme 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #162 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2019 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #228 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #434 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH YouTube Special Episode #2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor Re-United - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #167 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Reclamation - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #176 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #42 - Road Rage Edition: The Nightmare Begins | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #499 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Champions Vs. All Stars 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2016 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH At Our Best | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor 2021 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #238 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #141 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #50 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reach For The Sky - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Genesis 2011 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Hell Freezes Over | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor XV - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #312 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #64 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #90 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor II | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor II | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor II | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Genesis 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #216 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #39 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #314 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #238 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #411 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #111 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #421 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #260 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW G1 Supercard | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #145 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor VIII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Destination X 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #384 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #128 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #544 - Samoa Joe Hall Of Fame Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #544 - Samoa Joe Hall Of Fame Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2010 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Weekend Of Thunder - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #160 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #130 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW All Out 2022 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #392 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Saturday Night At Center Stage 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #272 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #96 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary VIII | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #120 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #128 - Road Rage Edition: 12th Anniversary Show - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Unauthorized | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH The Battle Lines Are Drawn | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH The Battle Lines Are Drawn | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XIII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #500 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #39 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Retribution: Round Robin Challenge II | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Retribution: Round Robin Challenge II | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #142 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #400 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #462 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #462 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #259 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #232 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #222 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Fourth Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Do Or Die II | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Summer Heat Tour - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Summer Heat Tour - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH A Night Of Hoopla | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Expect The Unexpected | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Brew City Beatdown | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #72 - Holiday Bash 2022 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #69 - Road Rage Edition: Final Battle 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JCW/UWA JCW Gets Lucky | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #364 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #108 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH The Homecoming 2005 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #308 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #256 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #256 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #110 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #56 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #165 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #146 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #237 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH The Golden Dream | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2002 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2002 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #200 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza V | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #223 - Best Of 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XII - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #179 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #252 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH State Of The Art 2019 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #167 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2016 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #96 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #117 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #160 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2018 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH 11th Anniversary | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Field Of Honor 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #308 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #88 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Best In The World 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| HOG Believe In The Glory | Jay Lethal | House Of Glory | Won |
| HOG Believe In The Glory | Jay Lethal | House Of Glory | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #231 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #105 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Summer Supercard | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #91 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #76 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| HOG Repentance | Jay Lethal | House Of Glory | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor IX | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 5 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #34 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #151 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2015 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor 2026 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #31 - Road Rage Edition: Showdown In The Sun - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #304 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Escape From New York | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Scramble Cage Melee | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH 14th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #249 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #104 - Road Rage Edition: All Star Extravaganza V | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor For All 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #150 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark #135 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| JCW Snow Day | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best In The World 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #119 - Best Of 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark #151 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #45 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| JCW | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #242 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Full Gear 2023 - Zero Hour | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #244 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Full Gear 2022 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #59 - Grand Slam 2022 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Sign Of Dishonor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Sign Of Dishonor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Final Resolution 2008 (Dezember) | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #248 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #262 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #262 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH The Homecoming 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Aftershock 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH The Nightmare Begins | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #244 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #48 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #110 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #341 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #286 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor Reigns Supreme 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #111 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Collision #140 - Spring BreakThru 2026 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #140 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor XI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JCW Skin To Win | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #416 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #156 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #157 - Anniversary 2022 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #91 - Road Rage Edition: Relentless | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #114 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #129 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #332 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road To Final Battle 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #169 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Steel Cage Warfare | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #179 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #84 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #377 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2021 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| CZW Best Of The Best VI: CZW vs. ROH | Jay Lethal | Combat Zone Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #259 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Stalemate | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #119 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Back To Basics | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH One Year Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH One Year Anniversary Show | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JCP Ric Flair's Last Match | Jay Lethal | Jim Crockett Promotions | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #49 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #162 - Championship Edition | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2011 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reach For The Sky - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #311 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2012 - Hostage Crisis | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Against All Odds 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Greatness - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #87 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Reclamation - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #506 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #136 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JCW Ace In The Hole | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| JCW Deal With The Devil | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Lost |
| ROH Field Of Honor 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Battle Of The Belts V | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #326 - Before The Glory | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Empire State Showdown | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Empire State Showdown | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best In The World 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Genesis 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH The Conclusion | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH The Conclusion | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH The Conclusion | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #81 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #357 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #134 - Road Rage Edition: Supercard Of Honor VIII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #450 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Masters Of The Craft 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor IV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor IV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2016 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor 2025 - Zero Hour | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #130 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Hard Justice 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #246 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #224 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #215 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #46 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #511 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #218 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #186 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #218 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #490 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road To Final Battle 2016 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #335 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #115 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #150 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #437 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor In The Heart Of Texas | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2017 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark #153 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Turning Point 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #419 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW All In London 2024 - Zero Hour | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Night Of The Grudges II | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best Of American Super Juniors Tournament | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #223 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #494 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Worlds End 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #107 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #149 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #149 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Testing The Limit | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #240 - Road Rage Edition: Honor Rising - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #276 - Best Of 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2017 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #91 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor XII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #214 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #479 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Gateway To Honor 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark #133 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #180 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Masters Of The Craft 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH State Of The Art 2018 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor XI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor IV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #401 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JCW TV Taping | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| ROH Honor Vs. Evil | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #547 - The History of Supercard of Honor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #491 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #320 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #113 - Road Rage Edition: Glory By Honor XII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #70 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #114 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Ring Of Homicide | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestlerave '03 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestlerave '03 | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #330 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dark #142 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #221 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2018 - Tag 2: Champions Vs. BULLET CLUB | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #136 - Slam Dunk Sunday 2026 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| JCW It's The Big One | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| ROH 16th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #67 - Best Of 2012: Part Two | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2016 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2019 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor United - London | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Main Event Spectacles | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Main Event Spectacles | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #114 - Road Rage Edition: Pursuit - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #177 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #153 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #199 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #353 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Steel City Excellence | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #493 - Championship Edition | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2011 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #198 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #228 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory IV | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #287 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #85 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza II | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Border Wars 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #339 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #405 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor X - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #253 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Genesis 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Killer Instinct | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #112 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2008 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Reborn: Completion | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #97 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best In The World 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #216 - Thanksgiving Eve 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Round Robin Challenge III | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Round Robin Challenge III | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #328 - Road Rage Edition: War Of The Worlds UK | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH A New Dawn | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH A New Dawn | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #183 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Field Of Honor 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #336 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Northern Aggression | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #342 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #173 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2018 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JCW Jersey J-Cup 2003 | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| JCW Jersey J-Cup 2003 | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| JCW Jersey J-Cup 2003 | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| JCW Jersey J-Cup 2003 | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| ROH 15th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2015 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Revenge On The Prophecy | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Revenge On The Prophecy | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2011 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor III | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #331 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #432 - G1 Supercard Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #133 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2014 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #248 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #162 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Trios Tournament | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #159 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #26 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Destination X 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VIII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #161 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2017: Pittsburgh | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2017 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Midnight Express Reunion | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Aftershock 2015 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #203 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #58 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/CMLL Global Wars Espectacular - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/CMLL, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Rise & Prove | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2017 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #206 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH The Battle Of Richmond | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #86 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #488 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #148 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #553 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #150 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #150 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Sacrifice 2007 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #318 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Collision #113 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #51 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Collision #59 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2019 Fallout | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard Of Honor VII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| IWA Mid-South The Revolution Strong Style Tournament 2006 | Jay Lethal | IWA Mid-South | Lost |
| ROH Future Of Honor #2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Future Of Honor #2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road 2010 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Raising The Bar - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Conquest Tour 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Live Strong | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road To G1 Supercard - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #343 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #196 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2017 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #23 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #548 - Jonathan Gresham - A Champion's Journey Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #500 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #171 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2004 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2004 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #297 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2018 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2017 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #291 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2024 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #176 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 6 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road To Final Battle 2016 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #480 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #278 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #189 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2015 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #108 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2016 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #229 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2021 - End Of An Era | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #329 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH 12th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #313 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #285 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War Of The Worlds 2019 - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Masters Of The Craft 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #379 - Best Of 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #43 - Road Rage Edition: Best In The World 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor X | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #337 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Undisputed Legacy | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Honor Re-United - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #278 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #243 - Jay Lethal Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #243 - Jay Lethal Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #243 - Jay Lethal Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #243 - Jay Lethal Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #243 - Jay Lethal Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #243 - Jay Lethal Special | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH A Night Of Tribute | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Gold | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #207 - Championship Edition | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #193 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #64 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Redemption | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Buffalo Stampede | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution 2010 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #169 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Summer Heat Tour - Tag 1: Aftershock | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #84 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #84 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #182 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #114 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #158 - Road Rage Edition: Death Before Dishonor XII - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #126 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor XIV: Champions Vs. All Stars | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Xplosion #272 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark #185 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Border Wars 2012 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #125 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #125 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2018 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JCW Crazy 8 | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Lost |
| AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #140 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW All Out 2023 - Zero Hour | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Enter The Dragon | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #181 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #485 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #343 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JCW The Battle At Bergenfield | Jay Lethal | Game Changer Wrestling, JCW (NJ) | Won |
| ROH The Last Stand | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Pursuit - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH State Of The Art 2018 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Soaring Eagle Cup | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #83 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Unity | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2018 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Lockdown 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 5 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2005 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Maximum iMPACT Tour 2009 - Tag 6 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Joe Vs. Kobashi | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Joe Vs. Kobashi | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #132 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #291 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary 2009 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH War Of The Wire | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH War Of The Wire | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #74 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #52 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2016 - Tag 5 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #118 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #255 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #29 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #100 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #130 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #311 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Saturday Night At Center Stage 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Third Anniversary Celebration - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Third Anniversary Celebration - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #168 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Live And Let Die | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #16 - Road Rage Edition: Southern Defiance | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor United - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH This Means War | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/CMLL Global Wars Espectacular - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/CMLL, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #315 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #172 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Dragon's Reign | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #148 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #307 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #51 - Fight For The Fallen 2022 - Tag 2 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT #242 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #80 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH YouTube Special Episode #1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor III | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #458 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #94 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH The Experience 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #344 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH on HonorClub #103 - Chris Jericho's Rock 'N' Wrestling Rager At Sea | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2015 - Tag 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #254 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road To Best In The World 2016 - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #269 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #269 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor United - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT #246 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling #408 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Gateway To Gold | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #439 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road To G1 Supercard - Tag 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH WAR | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Wrestling #264 - Road Rage Edition: Field Of Honor 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH 19th Anniversary Show - Hour One | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/MLP Global Wars Canada | Jay Lethal | MLP, ROH/MLP, Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/MLP Global Wars Canada | Jay Lethal | MLP, ROH/MLP, Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #88 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/CMLL Global Wars Espectacular - Tag 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| CZW Breaking Point: Let The Kaos Begin! | Jay Lethal | Combat Zone Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Bound For Glory 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice 2006 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best In The World 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #102 - Royal Rampage 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Xplosion #164 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA House Show | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH on HonorClub #6 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| RevPro High Stakes 2016 | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Won |
| TNA Genesis '11 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| FWE Welcome to the Rumble 2 | Jay Lethal | FWE | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Honor For All 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 10 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| TNA No Surrender '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH 11th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| UWF (Carolina) Rock 'n' Roll Express Tag Team Tournament - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina) | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Aftershock Tour - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Aftershock Tour - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Summer Shore Series - Royal Consequences 2 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #46 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor XIV - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Best In The World '16 - Day 2 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best In The World '16 - Day 2 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| FIP Big Year One Bash - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | FIP | Won |
| JAPW Stiff Dance | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #150 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Summer Supercard | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Holy Ouch! Fundraiser | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #219 - Winter Is Coming 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| WrestlePro Great Alaskan Bash: Palmer | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/PCW | Won |
| BTW Live In Webster | Jay Lethal | BTW | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| JAPW Spring Massacre | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WCPW Stacked 2017 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings at WrestleCon | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2019 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #44 - Part 2 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Best in the World 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2024 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #72 - Holiday Bash Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #244 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #179 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best in the World '17 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| wXw Superstars of Wrestling 2018 | Jay Lethal | wXw | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #162 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor X: State of Emergency | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice '07 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Field of Honor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| NEW Wrestlefest XI | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| JAPW Funkin' Homicide | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| NEW Holiday Havoc 2006 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Revolution 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem '19 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| Warrior Wrestling 25 | Jay Lethal | Warrior Wrestling | Lost |
| WrestleCade WrestleCade 2021 - Revenge | Jay Lethal | WrestleCade | Won |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Manhattan Mayhem | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| WrestlePro Violencetines Day | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| 5 Star UK Tour - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | 5 Star | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| FWE Haastility | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| WrestlePro All Hail the Maharaja | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| TNA Victory Road '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Sign of Dishonor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Sign of Dishonor | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Summer Shore Series - Memorial Day Massacre | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #70 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW All Out 2022 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Survival Of The Fittest | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Glory By Honor XVI - Night 2 TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WrestlePro On The Spot Title Shot Rumble | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Full F'N Force | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| NJPW King Of Pro Wrestling 2016 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #130 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #91 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Slammiversary VIII | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Saturday Night at Center Stage | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Caged Destiny | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Lockdown '09 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Seasons Beatings 2004 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #148 Taping - Part 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Haas of Pain | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| JAPW Russ Haas Memorial Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #114 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Testing The Limit | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Joe Vs. Kobashi | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Summer Shore Series - Unfinished Business | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #51 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2016 - Day 2: TV Taping | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2016 - Day 2: TV Taping | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH YouTube Special Episode #1 Taping - Part 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Turning Point '07 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| NJPW G1 Special in USA - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Lost |
| FWE Empire State Showdown | Jay Lethal | FWE | Lost |
| JAPW Coming Home: 7th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| Jericho Cruise/ROH Honor Club TV #103 Taping - Part 1 / Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea Six - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise/ROH | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2025 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Back to Business | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| JAPW Wild Card 3 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Full Gear 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark #185 Taping - Part 2 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| PWS Blitzkrieg | Jay Lethal | PWS | Won |
| WCPW Built to Destroy 2017 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Won |
| AEW Collision #46 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Conquest Tour - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Wanted Dead or Alive | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| NEW Autumn Ambush 2006 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| JAPW Wild Card II | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| UWF (Carolina) Rock 'n' Roll Express Tag Team Tournament - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina) | Lost |
| AEW All In London 2024 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Supercard of Honor XV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #26 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise/ROH Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise/ROH | Lost |
| JAPW Counterstrike | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #96 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise/ROH Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise/ROH | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #143 - Black Friday Taping - Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard of Honor 2025 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #173 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Charm City Excellence - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH State of the Art 2019 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #54 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW Wild Card | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH Final Battle 2015 - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #132 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Halloween Hell 2004 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Four Leaf Clover - Night 3 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise | Won |
| NEW Six Flags Slam Fest 2023 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| JAPW Double Header - Evening Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Road to Final Battle 2015 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW 8th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Summer Heat Tour - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| UWF (Carolina) Rock 'n' Roll Express Tag Team Tournament - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina) | Won |
| UWF (Carolina) Rock 'n' Roll Express Tag Team Tournament - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | UWF (Carolina) | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2015 - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| JAPW Unfinished Business | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Seasons Beatings 2003 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Rampage #110 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #69 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Unity | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| All Wheels Wrestling Pilot | RPM | All Wheels Wrestling | Won |
| All Wheels Wrestling Pilot | RPM | All Wheels Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #131 Taping - Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #103 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Free Enterprise | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #145 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Battle of the Belts III Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Reloaded Tour - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV: TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WSU/NWS King & Queen of the Ring Tournament 2009 | Jay Lethal | WSU/NWS | Won |
| WSU/NWS King & Queen of the Ring Tournament 2009 | Jay Lethal | WSU/NWS | Won |
| WSU/NWS King & Queen of the Ring Tournament 2009 | Jay Lethal | WSU/NWS | Won |
| ROH Best In The World '14 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #119 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #200 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| FIP Inverness Show (May '06) | Jay Lethal | FIP | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2021 - End of an Era | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA TNA Live | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Caged Fury | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Road to Final Battle: Tag Wars 2014 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #125 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| NEW Wrestling Under The Stars 2022 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| ROH 14th Anniversary TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Aftershock Tour - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW Beachwood Brawl | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| WCPW Refuse to Lose 2017 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Elite | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2019 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| TNA Destination X '09 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Supercard of Honor XII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| FIP Big Year One Bash - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | FIP | Lost |
| AEW All Out 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Boiling Point '12 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Third Anniversary Celebration Pt. 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Third Anniversary Celebration Pt. 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Back to Business 2007 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| JAPW Family Crisis 2 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| 5 Star Dominant Wrestling: Dundee | Jay Lethal | 5 Star | Won |
| AEW Battle of the Belts V | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Supercard of Honor VIII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Showdown in the Sun - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 4 | Jay Lethal | ROH/PCW | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #154 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| MXW Golden Quest | Jay Lethal | MXW | Lost |
| FWE No Limits 2012 | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| ROH TV #526 (airdate) | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Against All Odds '09 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| NJPW STRONG The New Beginning USA Tapings | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Lost |
| AEW Dark #133 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW 9th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| TNA No Surrender '07 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Wrestling's Finest | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| 5 Star UK Tour - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | 5 Star | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW International Invasion | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/PCW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| FIP Orlando Onslaught | Jay Lethal | FIP | Lost |
| WrestlePro Great Alaskan Bash: Anchorage | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| AEW Rampage #155 - Royal Rampage 2024 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Seasons Beatings 2002 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #217 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #159 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Fan Convention | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #39 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor 2017 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| NEW Autumn Ambush 2006 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| JAPW Student Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best in the World '12: Hostage Crisis | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Seasons Beatings 2007 (January Show) | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Winter Warriors Tour - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| FWE Back 2 Brooklyn | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| ROH TV #532 (airdate) | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2018 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Dragon's Reign | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Bound By Honor 2019 - Night 1 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Best in the World '13 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA Turning Point '10 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Awesome Sacrifice | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2015 - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Six on the Beach - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise | Lost |
| FWE X | Jay Lethal | FWE | Lost |
| JAPW Smarts Only | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH Survival of the Fittest 2018 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH The Experience | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #134 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Northern Aggression | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour - Day 5 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW G1 SuperCard | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| JAPW Seasons Beatings Tour - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| DREAMWAVE Good As Gold 2023 | Jay Lethal | DREAMWAVE | Lost |
| TNA Slammiversary '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #59 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Survival of the Fittest 2017 - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW When Worlds Collide | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| PWS Blitzkrieg II | Jay Lethal | PWS | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #170 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW 6th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Rampage #88 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #85 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| RevPro Uprising 2017 | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2016 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XII - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #156 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Hard Justice '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars '14 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW Gored! | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Honor Reigns Supreme 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WCPW Born to Destroy | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Won |
| JAPW Reclaiming Hudson | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| NEW Danbury Show | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Final Resolution (Dec '08) | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| AEW Dark: Elevation #45 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars 2017 - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2016 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Full Gear 2022 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| RevPro Risky Business 2020 | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #162 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW Rahway Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| NJPW STRONG Strong Style Evolved 2022 Taping | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #238 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Turning Point '08 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Glory by Honor XI | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Second to None | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Second to None | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Homecoming 2 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| RevPro High Stakes 2014 | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| FIP Crystal River Show (May '06) | Jay Lethal | FIP | Lost |
| BZW Bangover | Jay Lethal | BZW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Reloaded Tour - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| NJPW G1 Climax 26 - Day 19 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Summer Heat Tour - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Actions Speak Louder Than Words | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH Road to Best in the World '14 - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Raising the Bar - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Aftershock | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| WCPW Pro Wrestling World Cup - USA Qualifying Round | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Won |
| WCPW Pro Wrestling World Cup - USA Qualifying Round | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Won |
| ALL IN | Jay Lethal | N/A | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Steel City Excellence | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #64 Taping - Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| PWS Refuse to Lose 2012 | Jay Lethal | PWS | Lost |
| ROH Supercard of Honor X: TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Supercard of Honor X: TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Brotherly Love Fundraiser | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor: Fallout | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings - Conquest Tour - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW 13th Anniversary Show - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| TNA Lockdown '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WrestlePro Rock And Roll Forever | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VIII - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Collision #113 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #220 - Holiday Bash 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| OVW TV Taping (August '06 #4) | Jay Lethal | OVW | Lost |
| JAPW May Madness | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #129 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| NJPW G1 Climax 26 - Day 17 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Lost |
| TNA Victory Road '07 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #216 - Thanksgiving Eve 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Aftershock Tour 2016 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| LL USA Masked Warriors #13 | Jay Lethal | LL USA | Won |
| JAPW Calm Before the Storm | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Jersey City Rumble 2009 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| JAPW Jersey City Rumble 2009 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| NJPW G1 Climax 26 - Day 18 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #135 Taping - Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Caged Fury 2 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| AEW Collision #37 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Worldwide Internet TV Taping | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| JAPW Worldwide Internet TV Taping | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| WSU/NWS Edison Show | Jay Lethal | WSU/NWS | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Reloaded Tour 2016 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2020 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Fairfax Excellence | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Field of Honor 2015 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor NOLA | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| NEW Flippin' Out 2022 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| ROH Supercard of Honor IX | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Saturday Night At Center Stage 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Braintree Invasion | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| JAPW Braintree Invasion | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| RevPro Lethal Weapon | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Summer Shore Series - Boardwalk Bedlam | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH Enter The Dragon | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Global Wars '15 - Night #1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza V | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Gateway to Gold | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #77 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH 16th Anniversary | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Never Forget | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Collision #108 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| WrestlePro Alaska: 4th Anniversary SuperShow | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Lost |
| ROH Pursuit - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #254 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| The Crash Crash Wrestling | Jay Lethal | The Crash | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Six on the Beach - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise | Won |
| WrestlePro WrestleProlooza | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| NEW Spring Slam 2022 | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| ROH 14th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Wild Card 4 | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| NEW Bristol Show | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH The Last Stand | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| IWC Super Indy VI | Jay Lethal | IWC | Lost |
| ROH TV #513 (airdate) | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2018 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Reloaded Tour - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Reloaded Tour - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| NEW Bristol Show | Jay Lethal | NEW | Lost |
| ROH Windy City Excellence - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Final Battle '12: Doomsday | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #106 Taping - Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| NEW Torrington Show | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| ROH Glory By Honor 2021 - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Six on the Beach - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise | Lost |
| NJPW New Year Dash!! | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| JAPW Beat the Odds | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| NJPW New Japan Road ~ Ganbare! Uonuma 2016 ~ | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| ROH Glory by Honor XII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #51 - Fight For the Fallen 2022 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XVII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2019 - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2019 - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '08 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| WCPW Loaded #27 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH 17th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW 10th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| FWE Meltdown | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| ROH Best In The World '16 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| JAPW Tough Love | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AIW Barely Lethal | Jay Lethal | AIW | Won |
| ROH Summer Heat Tour - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Summer Heat Tour - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| NJPW Power Struggle 2016 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Lost |
| PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | Pro Wrestling Guerrilla | Won |
| JAPW 11th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #50 - Fyter Fest 2022 - Week 2 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH/CMLL Global Wars Espectacular - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | ROH/CMLL | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #6 Taping | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH/NJPW All Star Extravaganza VIII | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Four Leaf Clover - Night 4 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise | Won |
| RevPro Summer Sizzler 2013 | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Lost |
| AEW Rampage #97 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Escape From New York | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| JAPW Free Admission | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| Smash (Canada) Danger Zone | Jay Lethal | Smash (Canada) | Lost |
| ROH Second Anniversary Show | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Reborn: Completion | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TCW Relaunch Tour | Jay Lethal | TCW | Won |
| ROH TV #527 - VLNCE vs. Pure (airdate) | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Revolution 2024 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Fall Out | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| NJPW G1 Special in USA - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | NJPW | Won |
| WCPW Loaded #21 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Lost |
| AEW Worlds End | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #246 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Queen City Excellence 2017 - TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Winner Takes All - 15th Anniversary | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| PWS Super Card 2012 | Jay Lethal | PWS | Lost |
| AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| WCPW Loaded #2 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Lost |
| WrestlePro Alaska: Back With a Bang | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| ROH Supercard of Honor X | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Showdown in the Sun - Day 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TERMINUS 3 | Jay Lethal | TERMINUS | Won |
| 5 Star UK Tour - Day 3 | Jay Lethal | 5 Star | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Relentless | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #176 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| FWE Dysfunctional Family | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | Pro Wrestling Guerrilla | Lost |
| ROH Southern Defiance | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH Southern Defiance | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #89 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW Revolution | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 2 | Jay Lethal | ROH/PCW | Won |
| ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017 - Day 1 | Jay Lethal | ROH/NJPW | Won |
| ROH Death Before Dishonor XII - Night 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| Jericho Cruise/ROH Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea - Day 4 | Jay Lethal | Jericho Cruise/ROH | Won |
| PWS Firestorm | Jay Lethal | PWS | Lost |
| ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 3: TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| BZW Deadline 2025 | Jay Lethal | BZW | Won |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| ROH All Star Extravaganza VII | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| PWS Five Year Anniversary Weekend - Night 2 | Jay Lethal | PWS | Lost |
| Mystery Wrestling #11 | Jay Lethal | Mystery Wrestling | Won |
| JAPW The Homecoming | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Dynamite #291 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| WCPW Pro Wrestling World Cup - Round of 16 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Lost |
| LL USA Masked Warriors #12 | Jay Lethal | LL USA | Lost |
| JAPW Class of 2001 Student Show | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| ROH Final Battle 2013 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Best in the World TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| NEW Zero Fear | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| NEW Zero Fear | Jay Lethal | NEW | Won |
| AEW Rampage #59 - Grand Slam Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #111 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| JAPW Basebrawl | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| JAPW Seasons Beatings 2007 (December Show) | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Rampage #39 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA Victory Road '10 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Honor Club TV #130 Taping - Part 1 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| MXW Show #2 | Jay Lethal | MXW | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '07 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Do or Die II | Hydro | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| TNA TNA Live | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| WCPW Loaded #34 | Jay Lethal | WCPW | Lost |
| ROH 12th Anniversary Show | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH The Nightmare Begins | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA Lockdown '07 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| FWE Welcome to the Rumble | Jay Lethal | FWE | Lost |
| FWE Welcome to the Rumble | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| FWE Welcome to the Rumble | Jay Lethal | FWE | Won |
| JAPW Ultimate Rumble | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| JAPW Ultimate Rumble | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| AEW Collision #142 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| BTW Return Of The Dragon | Jay Lethal | BTW | Lost |
| JAPW Student Slaughter 2001 Hell Night | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Lost |
| ROH Border Wars '13 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH Steel City Excellence 2019 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Conquest Tour - Day 5 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| AEW Dynamite #342 | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA Sacrifice '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Best in the World 2021 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH TV Tapings - Aftershock Tour - Day 5 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| AEW Rampage #149 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| ROH NYC Excellence | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TERMINUS II | Jay Lethal | TERMINUS | Won |
| JAPW Hail to the King | Jay Lethal | JAPW | Won |
| AEW Rampage #109 Taping | Jay Lethal | All Elite Wrestling | Lost |
| WrestlePro Alwayz Rahway | Jay Lethal | WrestlePro | Won |
| ROH TV Tapings | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |
| ROH Honor Club TV #138 Taping - Part 2 | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Won |
| TNA iMPACT! Taping | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Won |
| RevPro Sittingbourne Spectacular 2014 | Jay Lethal | RevPro | Lost |
| TNA Genesis '06 | Jay Lethal | Total Nonstop Action Wrestling | Lost |
| ROH Honor United - London | Jay Lethal | Ring Of Honor | Lost |